OFFLINE REFERENCE-FRAME INSTRUMENT

Coin Rotation Paradox Lab

One motion. Several valid counts. The “extra” turn is the orbiting tangent frame.

ACTIVE RECEIVER

Equal circles · external rolling

In the laboratory frame the coin turns twice; in the co-rotating radial frame it turns once.

R : r = 1 : 1

Reference-frame comparator

external four perspectives
same motion · different frames · Space to pause
fixed circle R rolling coin r tracked marker centre path R ± r
Laboratory frame 0.000 turns absolute coin orientation
Radial frame 0.000 turns coin orientation minus orbit angle
Orbital frame 0.000 turns the tangent direction itself turns
No-slip residual 0.00e+0 contact-point speed in fixed frame

THE WHOLE “PARADOX”

Rolling contribution + turning reference frame

N_lab = (R + r) / r = R/r + 1 N_radial = R / r C_center = 2π(R + r)

For equal circles, the rolling centre travels a circle of radius 2r. Its path length is 4πr, exactly two rolling-coin circumferences.

PARADOX DISCERNMENT

The counts disagree because the frames disagree—not because the geometry does.

The laboratory frame counts the coin against fixed space. The radial frame rotates once with the orbit, so it subtracts one turn. The unwrapped tangent view sees only rolling along the fixed boundary. Each answer is meaningful only after naming its frame.

lab frame co-rotating frame tangent frame epicycloid no slip

INTERPRETATION BOUNDARY

A planar kinematics lab—not evidence for a cosmological mechanism.

The same reference-frame lesson can inspire analogies in astronomy, polarization, gears, and orbital motion, but analogy is not identity. This lab solves the rolling-circle geometry it actually models and keeps broader claims clearly separated.